Thanks for sharing your thinking wozy. If you read any of my ramble relative to my last 911SC I spent quite a bit of cash on it over the years, though having acquired a shed and tools enough over the years along with a modicum of experience I was able to do all the work myself, though spare parts prices were ever way more than Brit sports cars given Porsche charge more than the Light Brigade ever could..!!
Had I required to pay for others to carry out the very necessary REPAIRS then the cost of ownership would have been considerably higher, though fortunately servicing up to the 3.2 was a pretty simple and a relatively inexpensive task for a reasonably proficient spanner wielding owner when engine removal for whatever reason was a few hours work at most. Reading that on some water cooled Porsches engine removal in a fully equipped professional dealership might take 11 hrs..!!!! That is scary expensive indeed...?
The simplicity of the design of the air cooled and the engineering standards employed is much of that which attracted me to Porsche in the first place, and has caused me to retain a degree of interest in the marque. From all I have read complexity initially crept in when the digital age arrived in the shape of the 3.2, and from then on what were basic sports cars were forced to evolve to meet the expectations of those in search of more comfort and safety, perhaps not realising that ever increasing complexity would have to be engineered in to accomplish those ends, from then on adding horse power to compensate for the losses in terms of basic driver involvement seemed to be the way to go..?
Unfortunately for an old dude such as I the less driver involvement and more complexity and expense built in was a bit of a turn off, not to mention the other ...err...foibles that the design of water cooling brought with it for the flat six... Hmm..?
For sure any old air cooled seems likely to have or have had corrosion issues, and given the high mileages and many cumulative years of standing idle then having the nuts revved off it when a sunny dry day arrives, is perhaps not what comes to mind when looking at a wonderful layer of highly polished paintwork and thinking of purchase..?
Comparisons on cost benefit analysis between air cooled and water cooled seem complex also, given the hype around the Porsche brand, let alone the air cooled variety, one has only to look on YouTube to find amateur and professional film makers in their hundreds or more, waxing lyrical about the marque to the extent that air cooled values have created a market of their own in recent years. Of course the easy money years helped fuel that process.
The market is what it is TODAY, though looking ahead, I guess if you are a true enthusiast who hopes to ride out the whatever situation arises to a degree whereby your air cooled Porsche will continue to provide you with pleasure then GREAT.
I suspect there are many who run vintage sports cars and who have to search out spares at autojumbles or have them specially made, and may also require to run specialised fuels and lubricants and whatever other inconveniences might surface at any time, all the effort and expense thought more than worthwhile for a few wonderful trips in the sun whenever the stars align... (-: All of which is a tad different from running an air cooled today, but tomorrow, with the eco fuel taking over in the petrol stations of the UK on which the air cooled were not designed to run, it seems possible that evolutionary processes may in time affect the reduction ease of use, and thus the value of air cooled in the market..? However, as Jonttt ever proclaims, "they are not making any more of them." With that in mind assuming there may be enough real enthusiasts, they will ever find a way to enjoy their old Porsches if one such exists.... I hope.
Typing of true enthusiasts for their machines who live for a high degree of driver involvement at lower on road speeds you might like to beam up this vid and imagine comparisons of sorts for air cooled adventures at some future time...
Death-defying, Tiger Moth-Engined Thunderbug - YouTube
As for cost benefit analysis today, I suspect a well sorted 997.2 provides a degree of future proofing that the air cooled seems unlikely to achieve in terms of ever advancing regulation..? On the other hand I suspect there will ever be enthusiasts who may search out a more involving driving experience and at less than ballistic speeds of the sort that might shred your licence that an air cooled can provide...?
Given 997.2 are in £30k territory and far less likely to suffer structural corrosion issues, or have the high mileages that almost all air cooled should or would have when in a similar price range and may fit with your own modern and evolving motoring ideals, then fortunately the ever growing availability of track days would seem to provide the opportunity to stretch the legs of higher powered, safer water cooled Porsches and experience some real driver involvement without falling foul of the law ...?
It amuses me somewhat to read folk.. harking back.. to the mechanical more analogue experience of the earlier water cooled compared to the newer models, and again when others hark back to the non-turbo models of the much more recent water cooled as being preferable, or manual as opposed to super fast auto gear boxes... Seems it may just be down to the way we enthusiasts will ever enthuse...
ld: :floor: