Porsche 911 UK Enthusiasts Online Community Discussion Forum GB

Welcome to the @Porsche911UK website. Register a free account today to become a member! Sign up is quick and easy, then you can view, participate in topics and posts across the site that covers all things Porsche.

Already registered and looking to recovery your account, select 'login in' and then the 'forget your password' option.

Service history - OPC vs Indy.

SausageCreature

Barcelona
Joined
10 Jul 2011
Messages
1,495
I changed the oil a few thousand miles ago, in Feb this year. It was the first time I decided to do more frequent oil/filter changes than the 997 scehdule, and I was a little late in this particular interval to do it. Rather than go the full 2 years and 20k miles, I did it about 16k miles/14 months into the interval.

My old OPC service manager had no issues with doing the rest of the service, not changing the oil and filter and putting a stamp in the book. My OPC is now rigorous in adhering to procedure. So, even though the oil has only done a couple of thousand miles and been in for 3 months OPC insist on changing the oil if they are to stamp the book. Fair enough.

So, I am considering whether to:
1) try and find a more flexible OPC who will service but not change oil. This will keep the full OPC history
2) Go to an indy and lose the full OPC history.
3) Pay OPC for the full service including a rather unnecessary filter and oil change.

I cherish my car, and I wouldn't want to impact it's perceived reputation if a full main dealer history is consider to be a plus point over an indy specialist service history. This isn't about preserving re-sale value, or making it more attractive to a buyer. I cant really find the words to express what I am trying to "preserve" by having only OPC stamps in the book.

What do others think? I know many folk think that the indys care for our cars better than the OPCs. Is there any downsides to not being full OPC on the service book?

Waffley, I know. Sorry.
 
Servie history OPC vs Indy

Sausage :grin:

How old is you car? I'm pretty sure that there will be a million opinions on this but unless you are a fanatic about detail, after the original dealer new warranty has run out then indy workmanship should be acceptable to any potential buyer as long as you use good quality (OPC) parts. For example, my car was 6 years old in March, it had been serviced by main porsche dealers until it was over five years old (one minor around 20k and one major around 41k). when I bought it, about a year ago, I had new plugs, one new coil pack (cracked) new drive belt and brake fluid, all done by a local Indy (the guys are all ex Porsche technician's) with a stamp in the book. I will use indy's going forward. I think the important thing is that you can show the type and frequency of upkeep you give to your car rather than main dealers after a period of time. keep as many receipts as you can for all purchases and work and you should be good.

That my two cents on this anyway...good luck. :thumb:

John
 
After a period of time, most Porsche's will have a mix of both.

Overall is does no harm, come selling time as long as its been done and the car looked after.

As with any garage, there are good and bad ones around and prices.

The internet forums, are very helpful on good Indy's and OPC.
 
Cheers for the replies.

Yes, I might be feeling a little bit fanatical about the paperwork - OCD strikes again. The car is a 2004, so no spring chicken, but is in good condition and the "OPC replaced engine" has done less than 30k miles.

I would likely go to GCR if I was going to go to an indy. Although I might try my other local OPCs to see what they say. I have four within striking distance.

Mark
 
Regardless of what people say, an OPC history will always been worth more than an indie or mixed one. Now how much that will benefit you when it comes to resale is another question.

If you are fanatical about your car's paperwork then pay the relatively small amount to keep it. You are thinking about big changes to save a £100 or so. Hardly worth it in the long run.
 

New Threads

Forum statistics

Threads
124,610
Messages
1,442,061
Members
49,043
Latest member
MartynT
Back
Top