Porsche 911 UK Enthusiasts Online Community Discussion Forum GB

Welcome to the @Porsche911UK website. Register a free account today to become a member! Sign up is quick and easy, then you can view, participate in topics and posts across the site that covers all things Porsche.

Already registered and looking to recovery your account, select 'login in' and then the 'forget your password' option.

Air Bag, Below Lower Limit ???

Is that £380 for a 4 wheel geo alignment!!! :eek: :eek:

My Indy is £100 (or £90 when done with suspension work)
 
Carrerascott said:
Is that £380 for a 4 wheel geo alignment!!! :eek: :eek:

My Indy is £100 (or £90 when done with suspension work)


Thanks :sad:
 
deMort said:
That would appear to be the inner rack arms .. not the outer track rod ends , its not uncommon to have a small amount of play in these ..

I found it strange for many years that some cars have the play and other similar cars dont .. we finally put it down to speed bumps as the cars from speed bump areas were always the ones effected by this .

Ive never seen an excessively worn rack arm joint though .. ive changed plenty and you can do it with a 36 mm spanner .. special tool .. erm ..

I can only asume who ever did the job has never done one before or even worked on many Caymans , boxsters or 997 as it happens on all of them , my assumption here is it was the apprentise .. yup im that suprised atm ... they have ordered a crows foot spanner basically .

The cost though :eek: .. to be fair that doesnt do it justice so .. :eek: :eek:

Im gobsmacked as is everyone at work .. perhaps best if i just say an Indy is cheaper (not going to say what we would charge ) and you dont need a full geo .. you just need a front end adjustment .


For the fault code for the airbag which they couldnt fix ..

A car on a trickle charger .. it wont have a low voltage .. thats the point of a trickle charger .. even so ..

The car with the ignition on ( key in the lock ) does a self check of the airbag system .. this is when it may find faults .. also once moving it will continually make sure the system is fine , anything it sees no matter how quick it will flag a code , the light and shut down that part of the system .

The car has no idea of any faults on the system untill the key is in the ignition lock .. hence i often change airbag parts with no keys in the ignition and i never get a light on which i would do if the key was in .

You have an intermitant fault which may only happen for a millisecond but the car will see it and trigger the light .. this as you know can only be turned off by clearing the fault code .

For them to say its low battery voltage ... hmm .. ask them to explain that .. i for one would love to be sitting then when they tryed :D

The shame is you will still have an airbag fault , im guessing it will come back in a week or 2 .. if it helps i showed this to one of my collegues today .. more about the cost they charged you but when he read it he said .. that sounds like the clock spring to me .

Downside .. i cant see the car , its under warrenty anyways so all i can do is say what i think is wrong .. my guess is clock spring as is my collegues guess .

Youll just have to monitor it for now .. sigh .


deMort,

I'm not going to post just yet but the fees above have risen more, I have sent them an email asking them for some more details and I shall post here in due course.

The car went in with an airbag fault on Monday and I'm hoping to get it back tomorrow (Fri) or ???
But after a 'Health Check' for a 'Bit Of Play' in a track rod end I'm going to be in the region of £1600+ lighter.
Funny how this wasn't spotted in the MOT in Dec (some 200 miles before).

This is the first time I have used an OPC for a repair and I'm slowly loosing faith in them for any future repairs.

I shall keep you updated :?

Regards Swamps
 
Feel free to email if you want to as i realise not everyone wants to post details on the forum or if needed ill happily pm you my number and we can chat on the phone .

[email protected]

To be honest .. ive just made a thread in the general section about VHC ,s and im sorry to say .. this was my insperation for it .

As you say .. 200 miles from an MOT and no mention of play in the rack arms .. not so good :(

If you do have the video link from the VHC i would love to see it .. email above .
 
deMort said:
Feel free to email if you want to as i realise not everyone wants to post details on the forum or if needed ill happily pm you my number and we can chat on the phone .

[email protected]

To be honest .. ive just made a thread in the general section about VHC ,s and im sorry to say .. this was my insperation for it .

As you say .. 200 miles from an MOT and no mention of play in the rack arms .. not so good :(

If you do have the video link from the VHC i would love to see it .. email above .


Just sent :-O

Enjoy :)
 
deMort said:
Answered but atm i think it needs to stay private .. solve it then you can post here i feel .

As per phone call, many thanks :hand:

Swamps
 
I know the overheads running a workshop, and a dealer is a different league but 1.4k to fit two track rods and boots is taking the p***
 
Sorry if this is rubbing salt in but I have just done a back of a fag packet recon up. Now this is using non genuine parts but they are quality components. Two (TRW) track rods, two new rack boots fitting and full four wheel alignment on a Hunter wheel aligner and including vat it's less than £350. No I am awear that a Porsche specialist is going to cost a bit more and likely to fit genuine parts OPC is going to be a bit more again but for the life of me can't see how the hell they came to that figure.
 
Well I picked the car up this afternoon, price for
2 x track rods,
2 x track rod arms,
2 x gaiters and clips, &
four wheel tracking = £1532.46

But on a positive note on my 50min drive home the airbag light remained off :D

I'm going to put this one down to experience :grin:

I would just like to say a big 'THANK YOU' to deMort for all the input & advice regarding this :worship: :worship: :worship:

Swamps :)
 
Why did you need the track rod arms, surely the play is in the joints only?
 
MR997 said:
Why did you need the track rod arms, surely the play is in the joints only?

That is what I was told initially, so I agreed to have both track rod ends replaced.
But it appears that the joint on the track rod arm (inside the gaiter) also had some play, so they replaced the lot... :eek:

Swamps :)
 

Forum statistics

Threads
124,544
Messages
1,441,355
Members
48,956
Latest member
tobytobytoby
Back
Top